‘Inappropriate, insensitive’: Film on Christchurch mosque attacks angers members of Muslim community

A new film about the 2019 Christchurch terrorist attack has been criticized by members of the New Zealand Muslim community. The story of this movie is said to have misfocused on the white voice and the “story of the white savior.”

New Zealand-based entertainment news reports that New Zealand director Andrew Niccol is making the film, with Australian actress Rose Byrne starring as the central figure of New Zealand’s Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern.

The film’s producer said it was developed in consultation with members of the Canterbury Muslim community.

However, community members said they were unaware of the film’s production and criticized New Zealand’s Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern over the Muslim community.

“It’s frustrating that this was a tragedy in the Muslim community, but the story still begins a week later,” said Anjum Rahman of the Islamic Women’s Council in New Zealand.

“And I feel like we’re props for someone else’s story. It’s not appropriate for this kind of tragedy, and I really urge producers to rethink their approach.”

She should continue community-based efforts to target racism and white supremacist sentiment, threats still exist, and film depictions damage efforts to build social cohesion. Said there is a possibility.

“It’s good that the government has formed a board to support the victims. There are some moves, but this is part of a broader story. [of white supremacist views]..

“In Christchurch, two young Japanese have been beaten by two young white men. A few weeks ago, there was a video of a white supremacist threatening the Maori community in the news.

“So there’s still a lot to do, and while we’re telling a heroic story, we can’t forget what history is-or minimize or pretend it’s not there. I will. “

The movie’s title is “They Are Us,” a phrase used by Ms. Ardern in the aftermath of the shooting, killing 51 people and injuring more.

New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern unveiled a plaque at the Arnour Mosque in Christchurch on September 24, 2020.


Ardern moved away from the film and issued a statement that “the prime minister and the government are not involved in the film.”

Somali-born Muslim refugee scholar Guled Mile, who grew up in New Zealand, said the overall picture of the film was problematic and offensive.

“Another story, we ask who are” they “and who are” us. ”

“We haven’t even talked about these families who are still suffering. If such a movie happened, could we talk about the courage, the heroes, that happened in the Muslim community?”

“Some people still feel the influence from that day, so it’s probably too early for the movie.”

He said the portrayal of this Hollywood film did nothing to address the issues of New Zealand racism and the views of white supremacists.

“We all accepted the idea that we weren’t as racist as Australia or the United States, so when an attack like Christchurch happened, we were all shocked. Life in New Zealand was completely We were all shocked because we denied it.

“And I think this leads to a false depiction of who we are as a nation. Here in the United States, when talking to people [from New Zealand], They only want to talk to Jacinda Ardern.

“And to make a movie like this in Hollywood. But I don’t need that gaslight. Nobody needs it.

New Zealanders will place flowers outside the Arnour Mosque on the second anniversary of the 2019 attack.

New Zealanders will place flowers outside the Arnour Mosque on the second anniversary of the 2019 attack.


“Other parts of the world deserve to hear the reality of New Zealand’s daily life.”

Aya al-Umari, whose brother Hussein was killed in the attack, tweeted the classic Kiwi-ism “Yeah, no,” and said he was insensitive.

Oakland-raised journalist Mohammed Hassan said the film seems to be centered around Ms. Ardern at the expense of the affected communities.

“I can’t tell this story, I can’t turn it into a White Saver story,” he said in a Twitter message.

“This pain is still fresh and real. It’s upset, obscene and grotesque.”

Nicole and the film’s producer said the project aims to focus and uplift the “hero host.”

“They aren’t about the attack, but how the response to the attack (and) the unprecedented act of hatred was overcome by the overflow of love and support,” he reportedly said at the entertainment news deadline. I am.

“This movie deals with our common humanity, so I think it speaks to people all over the world.

“This is an example of what to do when a fellow human is attacked.”

The National Islamic Youth Association of New Zealand has launched a petition calling for “immediate cancellation” of the film.

Co-Chair NIYA Haris Murtaza said the film was “insensitive” and “tokenist” in consultation and portrayal of the Muslim community.

“The martyr, his family, and the wider community of victims are thoroughly consulted and deserve to be at the center of all projects related to the March 15 terrorist attack.

“Substances and individuals must not commercialize or profit from the tragedy that struck our community, nor should they treat such atrocities sensationally.”

In August 2020, an Australian man, Brenton Tarant, was sentenced to life imprisonment without parole for carrying out the attack.

Place of origin‘Inappropriate, insensitive’: Film on Christchurch mosque attacks angers members of Muslim community

Back to top button